1. Before You Start
Checking your pension thoroughly requires time and attention to detail. Set aside 2-3 hours for a comprehensive review, and choose a time when you won't be interrupted.
What You'll Need
- • Your most recent Annual Benefit Statement
- • Previous benefit statements (if available)
- • Employment records and contracts
- • Payslips showing pension contributions
- • Any pension transfers or service credits
- • Calculator and notepad
Understanding Your Pension Scheme
Before diving into the details, make sure you understand which pension scheme you're in and how it works. Different schemes have different rules, calculation methods, and potential error patterns.
Key Scheme Information
- • Which scheme you're in (NHS, Teachers, etc.)
- • When you joined
- • Which "section" applies to your service
- • Normal retirement age
- • Accrual rate (1/60th, 1/80th, etc.)
Common Error Areas
- • Missing or incorrect service periods
- • Wrong part-time percentages
- • Incorrect salary figures
- • McCloud remedy miscalculations
- • Transfer value errors
2. Gather Your Documents
Having the right documents is crucial for a thorough pension check. Here's what to collect and how to get missing documents:
Annual Benefit Statement (Essential)
This is your primary pension document, usually sent annually. It shows your current pension benefits and projections.
What it Contains:
- • Total pensionable service
- • Current salary
- • Projected retirement benefits
- • Death benefits
- • McCloud remedy calculations (if applicable)
How to Get It:
- • Check your online pension account
- • Contact your pension administrator
- • Ask your HR/payroll department
- • Should be provided automatically each year
Pension Service Extract (Recommended)
A detailed breakdown of your complete service history showing every employment period and how it's been recorded.
What it Contains:
- • Employment start/end dates
- • Part-time percentages
- • Salary details
- • Career breaks and their treatment
- • Transfer-in credits
How to Request:
- • Contact pension administrator directly
- • Usually free to request
- • May take 2-4 weeks to receive
- • Essential for detailed error checking
Supporting Documents
Employment Records:
- • Employment contracts
- • Job change notifications
- • Part-time working agreements
- • Maternity/paternity leave records
- • Sick leave documentation
Financial Records:
- • Recent payslips
- • P60 forms
- • Pension contribution statements
- • Transfer certificates
- • Additional voluntary contribution records
Pro Tip: Keep Copies
Make copies or scan all documents before starting your review. Keep originals safe and work from copies. This protects important documents and lets you make notes on the copies.
3. Basic Information Checks
Start with the basics. These simple checks can reveal obvious errors that might indicate bigger problems:
Personal Details Verification
Check These Details:
Full Name
Including any name changes due to marriage
Date of Birth
Affects normal retirement age calculations
National Insurance Number
Must match HMRC records exactly
Address
Ensure statements reach you
Why This Matters:
- • Wrong details can link to wrong pension records
- • Affects benefit calculations and projections
- • Can cause delays in processing
- • May indicate data quality issues
Current Salary and Contributions
Verify Against Payslips:
Annual Salary: Should match your current pay
Contribution Rate: Check percentage being deducted
Contribution Amount: Monthly/annual contributions
Pensionable Pay: May differ from gross pay
Common Issues:
- • Outdated salary information
- • Wrong contribution tier
- • Overtime/allowances not included
- • Part-time percentage incorrect
Benefit Summary Review
Look at the headline figures on your statement and ask: "Do these look reasonable?"
Quick Sense Checks:
- • Does total service match your employment history?
- • Do projected benefits seem reasonable for your salary/service?
- • Are there any obviously wrong figures?
- • Has anything changed unexpectedly from last year?
Red Flag Indicators:
- • Benefits much lower than expected
- • Large unexplained changes
- • Service total doesn't add up
- • Missing recent years of service
4. Service History Review
Your pensionable service is the foundation of your pension calculation. Even small errors here can have significant impact over time.
Service History Checklist
Go through your employment history year by year and check each period is correctly recorded:
For Each Employment Period:
- •Start and end dates are correct
- •No gaps in employment record
- •Part-time percentage is accurate
- •Job title and employer correct
- •Salary progression looks right
Special Attention To:
- •Career breaks (maternity, illness, etc.)
- •Changes in working hours
- •Job changes within the scheme
- •Transfers from other pension schemes
- •Periods of unpaid leave
Common Service Record Errors
Missing Service Periods
What to look for: Gaps between employment periods that should be continuous.
This often happens with short-term contracts, locum work, or when transferring between departments.
Impact: Every missing day is lost pension accrual.
Even short gaps can add up over a career to significant pension loss.
Incorrect Part-Time Percentages
What to check: Compare recorded percentage with your actual working hours.
Remember: this affects both service accrual and salary for pension calculations.
Common issues: Wrong percentages, not updated after hour changes.
NHS shift workers and teachers with varying hours are particularly affected.
Career Break Treatment
Protected periods: Maternity, paternity, adoption leave should count towards pension.
Check these periods show as "pensionable service" not "gaps."
Sick leave: Rules vary but many periods should be pensionable.
Long-term sick leave treatment depends on specific scheme rules.
Service Calculation Exercise
Try this simple calculation to verify your total service:
1. Add up all your employment periods (in years and days)
2. Adjust for part-time working (multiply by percentage)
3. Add any transfer-in service credits
4. Subtract any opt-out periods
5. Compare with the total on your pension statement
If there's a significant difference (more than a few months), investigate further or seek professional help.
5. Calculation Verification
Once you've verified your service record, check whether the pension calculations based on that service are correct.
Important Note
Pension calculations are complex and vary by scheme. This section covers basic checks you can do yourself, but professional verification is recommended for detailed calculation review.
Basic Calculation Checks
Annual Pension Estimate
Most schemes use a formula like: Service × Salary ÷ Accrual Rate
Example Calculation:
25 years service
× £35,000 salary
÷ 60 (1/60th accrual)
= £14,583 annual pension
What to Check:
- • Is the service figure correct?
- • Is the right salary being used?
- • Is the accrual rate correct for your scheme?
- • Are there any additional elements missing?
Salary Verification
Different schemes use different salary definitions for pension calculations:
Final Salary Schemes:
- • Usually best of last 3 years
- • May exclude irregular payments
- • Check calculation is using highest valid salary
Career Average Schemes:
- • Average of all pensionable pay
- • Revalued for inflation each year
- • Check revaluation factors are applied
Lump Sum Verification
Check your tax-free lump sum entitlement is correctly calculated:
Automatic lump sum: Some schemes provide automatic lump sum (often 3× annual pension)
Additional lump sum: You may be able to exchange pension for extra lump sum
Tax limits: Check calculations don't exceed 25% of total pension value
Rates used: Verify the exchange rates used for any pension-to-lump-sum conversions
When Calculations Look Wrong
If your calculations don't match the pension statement figures, don't assume you're wrong. Pension schemes have complex rules and exceptions that may not be immediately obvious.
Document your concerns and either contact the pension scheme directly or consider professional review. Many calculation errors are only discovered when someone looks carefully at the detail.
6. McCloud Remedy Checks
If you're affected by the McCloud Remedy, your pension statement should show additional calculations. Here's what to look for:
McCloud Remedy Indicators on Your Statement
Look For These Terms:
- • "McCloud remedy" or "Public Service Pensions Remedy"
- • "Underpin" protection
- • "Better deal" calculations
- • Separate legacy and reformed scheme figures
- • Service split 2015-2022
Missing McCloud Information:
- • No mention of remedy despite eligibility
- • Service after 2015 but no choice shown
- • Statement says "not affected" incorrectly
- • Benefits lower than expected for remedy period
McCloud Eligibility Check
Quick Self-Assessment:
Were you a member on or before 31 March 2012?
This establishes your eligibility for protection
Did you have service between 1 April 2015 - 31 March 2022?
This is the "remedy period" where choices apply
Are you still an active member or have you retired since 2015?
Covers most eligible members
If you ticked all boxes: You should see McCloud remedy calculations on your statement. If not, this needs investigation.
Common McCloud Errors
Incorrect Eligibility Determination
Being told you're not eligible when you should be, or vice versa. This is often due to incomplete service history data.
Wrong Service Period Split
Service from 1 April 2015 to 31 March 2022 should be subject to choice. Check these dates are correct in calculations.
Calculation Factor Errors
Using wrong accrual rates, retirement ages, or revaluation factors in the legacy vs reformed scheme comparison.
Missing "Better Deal" Analysis
The scheme should automatically give you the higher of legacy or reformed benefits. Check this comparison has been done.
7. Red Flags to Watch For
These warning signs suggest your pension may have errors that need professional investigation:
Service Record Red Flags
- ⚠Missing employment periods you know you worked
- ⚠Total service significantly less than your career length
- ⚠Incorrect part-time percentages for multiple periods
- ⚠Career breaks showing as unpensionable gaps
- ⚠Transfer credits that seem too low
Calculation Red Flags
- ⚠Pension much lower than expected for your service/salary
- ⚠Large year-on-year changes without explanation
- ⚠Salary figures that don't match your records
- ⚠Wrong normal retirement age being applied
- ⚠Lump sum entitlements that don't make sense
McCloud Red Flags
- ⚠No McCloud calculations when you should be eligible
- ⚠Told you're "not affected" despite service before 2012
- ⚠Service 2015-2022 not split correctly
- ⚠No "better deal" comparison shown
- ⚠Benefits lower than before McCloud implementation
Administrative Red Flags
- ⚠Difficulty getting clear answers to questions
- ⚠Inconsistent information between statements
- ⚠Long delays in processing requests
- ⚠Errors in basic personal details
- ⚠No response to queries about discrepancies
Trust Your Instincts
If something doesn't look right, it probably isn't. Pension administrators handle millions of cases and errors do occur. Don't assume they're always correct - many significant errors are only discovered when members question the details.
8. When to Get Professional Help
While you can do basic checks yourself, professional pension review may be worth considering in these situations:
High-Value Cases
- • Long service records (20+ years)
- • High salaries or senior positions
- • Multiple employer changes
- • Significant pension transfers
- • Complex employment history
Why: Higher potential error value makes professional review cost-effective
Complex Situations
- • Multiple career breaks
- • Part-time working for extended periods
- • Job-share arrangements
- • NHS/emergency services shift work
- • Teaching with different contracts
Why: Complex rules increase error likelihood and require expertise to verify
McCloud Affected Members
- • Eligible for McCloud remedy
- • Service spanning 2015-2022 period
- • Uncertainty about eligibility
- • No McCloud calculations shown
- • Retirement planning within 5 years
Why: McCloud errors are common and can be worth thousands
Red Flag Situations
- • Multiple red flags identified
- • Pension scheme unable to explain issues
- • Significant discrepancies found
- • Previous errors discovered
- • Retirement imminent
Why: Red flags often indicate larger problems requiring investigation
What Professional Review Includes
Comprehensive Analysis:
- • Complete service history verification
- • Detailed calculation checking
- • McCloud remedy verification
- • Transfer value analysis
- • Tax implication review
Expert Support:
- • Qualified pension specialists
- • Scheme-specific expertise
- • Error identification and quantification
- • Liaison with pension administrators
- • Clear reporting and recommendations
Cost vs. Benefit
Professional pension review typically costs a few hundred pounds but can identify errors worth thousands. Consider it as insurance for your retirement security.
Many providers offer "no error, no fee" arrangements, meaning you only pay if errors are found. This eliminates the financial risk of the review.
Take Action Today
Don't wait until retirement to discover pension errors. Regular checks can identify issues early when they're easier to fix.
DIY Check
Use this guide to review your own pension records
Professional Review
Get expert analysis for complex situations
Stay Updated
Regular checks catch problems early